95% solved, then failing every case
Topped Toys, a Canadian Shopify store, had the Gorgias team set up its AI support agent. The setup took several weeks. The agent followed logic the vendor wrote, including editing and cancelling orders, and answered customers on its own. The owner writes that it worked well for a few months. Then the answers changed: the agent forgot what the store sells, recommended products it does not carry, stopped following the order logic, and promised customers things the store cannot do. Support replies at the second level took over 36 hours, and the team that built the agent offered no support. The owner disabled it.
Start with one job only. Fill in the three lines. Keep the bot on that job.
The one job this bot does: ______________________________
What it may do on its own: ______________________________
What it must ask me first: ______________________________
Two lines from this case, side by side. No new figures.
Topped Toys, a Canadian Shopify store, had the Gorgias team set up its AI support agent. The setup took several weeks. The agent followed logic the vendor wrote, including editing and cancelling orders, and answered customers on its own. The owner writes that it worked well for a few months. Then the answers changed: the agent forgot what the store sells, recommended products it does not carry, stopped following the order logic, and promised customers things the store cannot do. Support replies at the second level took over 36 hours, and the team that built the agent offered no support. The owner disabled it.
Per the owner's review: the agent went from solving about 95% of issues to failing in 100% of cases, in his words. He says the working months convinced him of the value of this kind of agent, and he would pay close to a full-time salary for one that is supported. The failure he names is not the idea; it is the change with no support behind it (owner's review on the Shopify App Store, January 4, 2026).
The after line is the source's claim, not our measurement.
smalloffice.space · Get a case like this in your inbox each morning. Subscribe free
Read this case on your phone now, and keep it for later. Type your email. We send this case to that address, and you get the next cases each morning too.